The noise limit that blocks American high-speed rail was set from measurements of trains running before 1976, and the FRA has proposed an alternative at 96 decibels
Nothing in the United States runs faster than 150 miles an hour.
The Federal Railroad Administration says so in the second paragraph of a proposal it filed on Friday, and the sentence is the point of the whole document. The noise limits American railroads must meet were built from Environmental Protection Agency measurements of locomotives and railcars operating before 1976, when the fastest a train was allowed to go was 110 mph. Those limits are 90 decibels for a locomotive and 93 for a railcar.
Above about 160 mph, air becomes the loudest thing on a train. The agency writes that the aerodynamic noise is impractical or impossible to avoid, which means the old numbers do not merely constrain high-speed rail in the United States. They prevent it.
What Congress did, and when
The fix was authorised almost five years ago. Section 22423 of the infrastructure act signed in November 2021 amended the Noise Control Act to let the Transportation Department write standards for trains above 160 mph, in consultation with the EPA, and left the existing standards in place below that speed.
Friday is when the proposal to use that authority appeared.
The number
The alternative standard is an equivalent sound level of 96 dB(A) across a train pass-by, referenced to 160 mph. That reads louder than the rules it sits beside, and the agency is careful about why: it is measured at 25 feet rather than 100, and it is a different metric.
Faster trains get more room, by formula. Normalise the measurement back to 160 mph, subtract fifty times the log of the speed ratio, and compare. At 220 mph the ceiling works out at roughly 103 dB(A). Past 220 the formula stops, and anything faster goes through a special approval process instead.
The European specification for electric multiple units up to 155 mph caps at 95 dB(A), which the agency normalises to 96 for the purposes of this rule. It says it cannot adopt the European standard wholesale but invites comment on doing so.
None of it is compulsory. A railroad can keep testing against the 1970s limits at any speed it likes.
The economics are small on both sides. Over 30 years the agency puts the cost of the rule at $105,462 in present value terms, against $65.9m of benefits, which is $8,499 a year in testing costs and $5.4m a year saved by not having to quieten trainsets that were never loud in the way the old rule assumes.