The FDA is reopening a comment period that closed on 6 July, on a rule that takes the word gender out of 34 provisions of its regulations
The comment period that reopens on Monday closed on 6 July.
That is the substance of a notice the Food and Drug Administration filed for public inspection on Friday morning. It reopens, for a further 60 days, comment on a proposed rule published on 6 May at 91 FR 24380, which would remove the word gender wherever it appears in Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations and either replace it with sex or delete the reference. The original period ran to 6 July. The notice was filed 25 days after that, and the reason it gives for reopening is that the agency wants to allow interested persons additional time to submit comments. It reports no comment count and names nobody who asked. It is signed by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., as Secretary of Health and Human Services, rather than by the Commissioner of Food and Drugs.
FDA states that it is acting to comply with Executive Order 14168, issued on 20 January 2025, whose section 3(c) directs that when administering or enforcing sex-based distinctions every agency and every federal employee acting officially shall use the term sex and not gender in all applicable federal policies and documents. Section 2(a) of the order defines sex as an individual's immutable biological classification as either male or female.
Thirty-four provisions, and where they sit
The proposed rule lists them in a table. They run across 16 parts of Title 21 and they are more specific than a terminology change usually is.
Two are institutional review board rules at 21 CFR 56.107, one of which is the requirement that no board consist entirely of men or entirely of women. One is an infant formula records provision. Three are clinical hold provisions at 312.42, covering the hold that applies when a study of a drug for a life-threatening condition excludes men or women of reproductive potential, together with its exceptions for studies pertinent only to one sex and for studies run alongside a second study that excludes nobody. Six are adverse event reporting rules for drugs, biologics and devices. Two are new drug application content requirements. Two cover premarket tobacco product applications.
Eleven are device classification regulations, and they name products. A total 25-hydroxyvitamin D mass spectrometry test system. A device to detect non-microbial analytes to aid assessment of patients with suspected sepsis. A genetic health risk assessment system, five cardiovascular indicators including coronary vascular physiologic simulation software, an eye movement assessment aid for traumatic brain injury, and a computerized cognitive assessment aid for concussion.
What the amended text does
Read against the current regulations, the edits are narrow. The revised meeting rule at 10.65(d)(3) bars an agency representative from knowingly joining a meeting closed on the basis of sex, race, or religion. The revised board membership rule keeps the substance intact: no board entirely of one sex, the institution to consider qualified persons of both sexes, and no selection made on that basis. The clinical hold text keeps its trigger, its examples, which are studies of the excretion of a drug in semen and of effects on menstrual function, and its concurrent-study exception.
The number FDA puts on it
Zero.
Annualized benefits are given as $0 at both a 3 and a 7 percent discount rate. Annualized costs are given as 0 at both. Present value of costs, of cost savings and of net costs over a perpetual horizon are each $0. The rows for state, local or tribal government, for small business, for wages and for growth each read none. FDA writes that the rule reflects editorial changes that affect FDA rather than industry practice, that it anticipates no measurable change in industry, and that it expects no loss of public health benefits. The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs determined the proposal is not a significant regulatory action.
Any final rule would take effect 30 days after it publishes. Comments close 60 days after Monday.