The FCC votes Thursday on repealing the 39 percent national television ownership cap, and the draft order argues that is no radical departure because the UHF discount already permits 78 percent
Thirty-nine percent.
That is the share of American television households a single owner may reach, and on Thursday the Federal Communications Commission votes on deleting the rule that says so. The draft Report and Order went out on 16 July, and the Sunshine notice filed on 30 July put it on the agenda for the open meeting at 10:30 a.m. on 6 August. Appendix A of the draft is short. It amends part 73 by removing and reserving paragraph (e) of section 73.3555, which is the national television multiple ownership rule entire.
That paragraph holds two things, and the second is what makes the first misleading. Subparagraph (e)(1) is the 39 percent cap. The same rule also provides that a UHF station is attributed only 50 percent of the television households in its market when compliance is counted, the provision known as the UHF discount, and the draft is candid about what it does to the size of the change now proposed.
"Given that the UHF discount already allows television licensees to reach a potential 78% of the nation's households," paragraph 23 reads, "we believe that repeal will provide needed relief to station owners without constituting a radical departure from the current ceiling."
So the figure in the rule is 39, the figure in practice is 78, and the order's argument for removing the first is the existence of the second.
Nobody is close to either. Counting with the discount, the draft puts the reach of the Big Four networks through their own stations at 24.2 percent for FOX, 21.8 percent for CBS, 20.7 percent for ABC and 19.4 percent for NBC.
Authority is where this gets fought. Congress moved the cap to 39 percent in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, and the draft's answer is that Congress did it by directing the Commission to modify its rules rather than by writing a cap into statute, which the Commission reads as leaving itself free to repeal what it was told to write. Attorneys general from eight states filed against that reading in 2018 comments. The FCC's own document index lists a news release of 15 July headed "Gomez on Unlawful Plan to Eliminate National TV Ownership Cap."
The cap has been bending in practice already. The Media Bureau waived it in March to clear Nexstar's purchase of Tegna, and on 9 July the D.C. Circuit denied motions to stay that order pending appeal. Repeal would retire the waiver route by removing the thing that needs waiving.